Closed (by creator of list)

1.
A Superior Death (Anna Pigeon, #2)
A Superior Death (Anna Pigeon, #2) 3.92 avg rating — 12,779 ratings
2.
The Tale of Halcyon Crane
The Tale of Halcyon Crane 3.88 avg rating — 10,015 ratings
2.
Secret of the Porcelain Cats
Secret of the Porcelain Cats 3.67 avg rating — 3 ratings
2.
Whistle Up the Bay
Whistle Up the Bay really liked it 4.00 avg rating — 24 ratings
5.
Danger at the Border (Northern Border Patrol #1)
Danger at the Border (Northern Border Patrol #1) 4.19 avg rating — 254 ratings
5.
Peachtree Island
Peachtree Island 4.62 avg rating — 53 ratings
7.
Winter Study (Anna Pigeon, #14)
Winter Study (Anna Pigeon, #14) 3.87 avg rating — 9,309 ratings
7.
The Questing Heart
The Questing Heart 3.57 avg rating — 7 ratings
9.
Island Secret
Island Secret 0.00 avg rating — 0 ratings
10.
Samantha's Secret Room
Samantha's Secret Room
by: Lyn Cook
4.04 avg rating — 94 ratings
11.
Wreck at Ada's Reef (The Swallowtail Legacy #1)
Wreck at Ada's Reef (The Swallowtail Legacy #1) 4.06 avg rating — 482 ratings
12.
The Ghost of Put-In-Bay
The Ghost of Put-In-Bay 3.25 avg rating — 57 ratings
13.
Put-in-bay's Island Fever
Put-in-bay's Island Fever 0.00 avg rating — 0 ratings
14.
The sabertooth; a romance of Put-in-Bay
The sabertooth; a romance of Put-in-Bay 0.00 avg rating — 0 ratings
15.
Back to Put-in-Bay
Back to Put-in-Bay 0.00 avg rating — 0 ratings
16.
Rainbow's End
Rainbow's End 3.49 avg rating — 49 ratings
17.
The Secret of Bete Grise Bay
The Secret of Bete Grise Bay 4.43 avg rating — 7 ratings
18.
Leaving the Bellweathers
Leaving the Bellweathers 3.60 avg rating — 242 ratings
19.
Blackfly Season (John Cardinal and Lise Delorme Mystery, #3)
Blackfly Season (John Cardinal and Lise Delorme Mystery, #3) 3.80 avg rating — 3,063 ratings
20.
Phantom Victory
Phantom Victory 4.08 avg rating — 36 ratings
21.
To Keep the South Manitou Light
To Keep the South Manitou Light 3.81 avg rating — 16 ratings